Board Effectiveness

See your board as it really is.

Board effectiveness depends on more than the right CVs around the table. It depends on how directors decide, challenge, trust and work together, in the room and under pressure. CJPI's board effectiveness reviews combine personality dynamics with interviews, simulations and observation to give you an honest picture of how your board performs today, and what might make it better.

Board table illustration with directors seated around it, lines showing working relationships and one director highlighted, representing board dynamics and effectiveness

Strong Individuals Don’t Always Make a Strong Board

Boards fail less often for lack of expertise than for how they work together. Discussions dominated by a few voices, too much time on operations and too little on strategy, or non-executives who take management’s view on trust are all areas for boards to consider.

The 2024 UK Corporate Governance Code asks the chair of a FTSE 350 company to commission an externally facilitated board performance review at least every three years, and PE-backed and private boards face the same questions from their investors. Our reviews give chairs and sponsors independent evidence and a clear plan of action.

A review report with findings and recommendations
The Board Dynamics Report
Personal feedback for every director
An action plan agreed with the board
A profile of what the next appointment should add

Personality and Reality, in One Picture

Every review is scoped around the questions the Chair or sponsor needs answered. We draw on four sources of evidence:

Board Dynamics
Each director completes the CJPI Leadership Assessment. We combine the results to show how the board is likely to work together, its natural decision style and where it may have blind spots in our Board Dynamics Report.
Interviews
We carry out confidential one-to-one conversations with directors and, where useful, senior executives and the wider team to immerse our experts into each board member, their approach and their alignment with colleagues.
Simulations
Where appropriate, our leadership experts - led by experienced board members and supported by our executive coaching team run realistic board scenarios that show how the board handles pressure, challenge and difficult decisions.
Observation
Our team attends board and committee meetings to see how discussion, challenge and decision-making really work in practice, observing and considering how our evidence and assessments align in practice.

Comparing how the board is wired with how it actually behaves shows where natural strengths are being used, and where habits are holding the board back.

Board Dynamics, interviews, simulations and observation combining into a complete picture of the board
Inside the report

A Clear View of Your Board as a Team

The CJPI Board Dynamics Report brings together each director’s CJPI Leadership Assessment to show how the board is likely to work as a team.

Where the board sits on nine leadership scales, and the perspectives it lacks
How decisions get made: deliberate or decisive, harmonious or challenging, strategic or operational
Team role coverage: which of eight contributions are covered, crowded or missing
Key relationships: Chair–CEO fit, CEO and executive directors, executives and non-executives
Strengths, risks and questions for the board to explore

How It Works

Step 1
Scope
We agree the objectives, sources of evidence and timetable with the Chair or sponsor.
Step 2
Gather Evidence
Leadership assessments, interviews, simulations and observation, as scoped.
Step 3
Report & Facilitate
We present our findings to the board, facilitate the discussion and agree priorities. Every director receives personal feedback.
Step 4
Follow Through
Development, coaching and future appointments, where needed.
Who it’s for

Built for Boards at Every Stage

Listed Company Boards
An independent board performance review that supports your UK Corporate Governance Code reporting.
PE Sponsors & Portfolio Boards
Check the board is set up to deliver the value-creation plan, at the deal or mid-hold.
New or Changing Boards
A new Chair or CEO, or several new appointments, and a need to set ways of working early.
Nomination Committees
A clear view of the gaps before the next non-executive or executive search.
From insight to appointment

Fill the Gaps That Matter

Where a review shows a gap, such as no natural challenger or innovator, we can turn the board’s profile into a 360° ideal for the next appointment, so candidates are assessed against what your board actually needs.

Frequently Asked Questions.

Here’s some questions our clients typically ask us.

It depends on your scope. It can range from a focused Board Dynamics review to a full review with interviews, simulations and observation. We agree the right mix with the Chair or sponsor.

No. It describes natural working style, not ability, experience or performance. That is why we combine it with evidence of how the board actually behaves.

Each director completes a short online questionnaire. Interviews are arranged around directors’ diaries, and observation takes place at scheduled meetings.

Personality results are shared only with each director’s consent and held in line with UK GDPR. Interview comments are reported without attribution.

We are open about it. We confirm any other relationship with your company at the outset, so you can report it in your annual report.

Understand Your Board

Speak to us in confidence about a board effectiveness review.

Name