A Guide to Different Leadership Styles and How To Leverage Them

Leadership, often defined as the art of influencing and guiding others towards a shared goal, is a complex and multifaceted concept. Effective leaders possess a blend of qualities, including strategic thinking, communication prowess, and the ability to motivate and inspire their teams. While there is no one-size-fits-all approach to leadership styles, understanding different leadership styles and their strengths and weaknesses is crucial for navigating a career in leadership.

6 Different Leadership Styles

Firstly, we need to explore the different ways in which leaders lead. We’ve put together the six most common leadership styles and their potential strengths and weaknesses:

1. Authoritarian Leadership (Autocratic):

The epitome of control, authoritarian leaders command absolute authority, making decisions unilaterally and dictating instructions to their team. This style thrives in situations that demand decisive action and unwavering adherence to established plans. However, its rigid structure can stifle creativity, hinder innovation, and erode employee morale.

Potential Strengths:

  • Rapid decision-making
  • Clear direction and guidance
  • Efficient task completion

Potential Weaknesses:

  • Lack of employee engagement
  • Suppression of creativity
  • Potential for resentment and resistance

2. Participative Leadership (Democratic):

Empowerment is the cornerstone of participative leadership. These leaders encourage open communication, involving team members in decision-making and valuing their input. This builds a sense of ownership, shared responsibility, and increased job satisfaction.

Potential Strengths:

  • Enhanced employee engagement
  • Increased ownership of goals
  • Fosters collaborative problem-solving

Potential Weaknesses:

  • Slower decision-making
  • Potential for indecisiveness
  • Requires strong conflict resolution skills

3. Delegative Leadership (Laissez-Faire):

Trust, autonomy, and independence are the hallmarks of delegative leadership. These leaders grant significant freedom to their team members, allowing them to make decisions, manage their work, and take ownership of their tasks. This style empowers individuals, boosts morale, and develops a sense of self-reliance.

Potential Strengths:

  • Empowered and motivated employees
  • Increased sense of independence
  • Reduced micromanagement

Potential Weaknesses:

  • Lack of clear direction
  • Potential for confusion and prioritisation issues
  • Requires high levels of employee maturity and self-motivation

4. Transformational Leadership:

Transformational leaders elevate the game, igniting passion, inspiring innovation, and driving organisational change. They articulate a compelling vision, communicate high expectations, and empower their subordinates to think beyond the ordinary. This style fosters a culture of excellence, collaboration, and personal growth.

Potential Strengths:

  • Inspires innovation and creativity
  • Drives organisational change
  • Fosters high employee morale and motivation

Potential Weaknesses:

  • Requires strong communication and emotional intelligence
  • May be difficult to replicate across teams
  • Requires investment in employee development

5. Transactional Leadership:

Based on clear expectations, performance goals, and rewards, transactional leadership focuses on maintaining order, monitoring performance, and providing incentives for meeting objectives. This style is effective in ensuring task completion and maintaining consistency.

Potential Strengths:

  • Maintains order and consistency
  • Ensures task completion
  • Provides clear incentives for desired behaviours

Potential Weaknesses:

  • May lack emotional connection and inspiration
  • It can create a sense of dependency on rewards
  • May overlook intrinsic motivation and growth

6. Situational Leadership:

Acknowledging the dynamic nature of leadership, situational leadership emphasises adaptability. Leaders assess their team members’ maturity, experience, and motivation, selecting the most appropriate style for the given context. This flexible approach ensures effective leadership across a range of situations.

Potential Strengths:

  • Adapts to the specific needs of the team
  • Leverages individual strengths and motivations
  • Addresses team dynamics and individual needs

Potential Weaknesses:

  • Requires a keen understanding of individuals and situations
  • May be more challenging to implement consistently
  • Requires adaptability and flexibility

Selecting Leadership Styles

Becoming an effective leader requires recognition that leadership styles are not universally applicable. Instead, leaders should work to embrace the spectrum of styles, adapting their approach to the unique demands of each situation, team, and individual. This flexibility allows them to inspire, motivate, and guide their teams towards achieving shared goals and developing a thriving organisational culture. When leaders go through a leadership recruitment process, knowing your leadership styles and providing examples of how you have applied them flexibly is a great interview tip.

Here are some of the key reasons why effective leaders are flexible:

  • Different situations may require different leadership approaches. For example, in a crisis, a leader may need to take a more directive, autocratic approach to get things done quickly and efficiently. In a more stable environment, a leader may be able to delegate more responsibility and empower their team members to take ownership of their tasks.
  • Different team members may have different needs. Some team members may thrive in a more structured, hierarchical environment, while others may prefer more autonomy and freedom. A good leader can assess the needs of each team member and tailor their approach accordingly.
  • The overall organisational culture can also influence the most effective leadership style. A company that values innovation and creativity may be more open to a hands-off, laissez-faire leadership style, while a company that operates in a highly regulated industry may require a more structured, authoritative leadership approach.

Adjusting Leadership Styles

Effective leaders can understand these nuances and adjust their leadership style accordingly. They are also able to communicate their expectations clearly and consistently, and they are always willing to provide support and encouragement to their team members.

Here are some examples of how effective leaders can flexibly adapt their leadership style:

  • A leader might use a more directive approach when giving instructions to a new team member, but then allow them to take on more autonomy and responsibility as they get more experience.
  • In a meeting with a group of stakeholders, a leader might take on a more facilitative role, allowing the team to discuss and debate different ideas, but then step in and make a decision when consensus cannot be reached.
  • A leader might use a more inspirational approach when motivating a team to work towards a difficult goal, but then switch to a more motivating approach when they need to help the team deal with a setback.

By being flexible and adaptable, good leaders can create a more positive and productive work environment for their teams, and they can help their organisations achieve their goals.

Chris Percival

Chris is the Founder & Managing Director of CJPI and a Fellow of the Institute of Leadership.

You might also find these insights interesting...

What Makes a Great Leader?

Great leaders are the backbone of successful organisations. They possess...

How Does Generative AI Reshape The Leadership & Senior Talent Landscape?

The boardroom has long been a bastion of human experience...