How Market Mapping Can Help With Informed Hiring Decisions

How Market Mapping Can Help With Informed Hiring Decisions

Most senior hiring decisions are made with surprisingly little information about the market. A shortlist of four or five candidates tells you who was available and interested at one moment in time. It does not tell you who else is out there, how strong your shortlist really is, how comparable organisations structure the role, or what the right package looks like. Market mapping fills that gap, and it changes the quality of the decisions boards make about senior people.

This guide explains what market mapping is, what a good map gives you, the difference it makes to senior hiring and succession decisions, and when it is worth commissioning.

What is market mapping?

Market mapping, also called talent mapping, is the structured process of identifying and profiling the people who hold relevant roles across a defined set of organisations, whether or not they are looking for a move. The result is a picture of the talent market for a particular role or function: who the strongest people are, where they sit, what their responsibilities are, what they are likely to be paid and how open they might be to a conversation.

It is different from a job advert, which only reaches people who are looking, and different from a database search, which only reaches people who happen to be registered. A map covers the whole market, including the people who are busy succeeding where they are.

What does a good market map include?

ElementWhat it tells you
Target organisationsCompetitors, adjacent sectors and businesses with transferable experience, agreed with you at the outset
Named individualsWho holds the relevant roles, with their career history and scope of responsibility
Organisation structuresHow comparable teams are designed, sized and report
Remuneration insightIndicative packages for the role in the current market
Diversity of the talent poolThe realistic shape of a balanced longlist
Initial soundingsWhere appropriate, an early read on availability and interest

How market mapping improves hiring decisions

It shows you the whole field. Without a map, you compare candidates with each other. With one, you compare them with the market. That is the difference between choosing the best person who applied and choosing the best person for the role.

It tests the brief before you commit to it. Mapping often reveals that the ideal profile is rarer than expected, sits in a different sector or costs more than budgeted. Finding that out before a search starts saves months and avoids a failed process.

It sets the package on evidence. Real market data on remuneration and structure helps you offer enough to attract the right people without overpaying, and reduces the risk of losing a preferred candidate at offer stage.

It strengthens succession planning. A map lets you benchmark internal candidates against the external market, which is essential for a credible plan. Our guide to building a succession planning template explains where this fits.

It speeds up future hiring. When a role becomes vacant, an up-to-date map means you already know who to approach. Time to hire falls and the risk of a long, costly vacancy reduces. Our time-to-hire impact calculator shows what a prolonged vacancy can cost.

It informs organisation design. Seeing how comparable organisations structure a function, and where their leaders came from, is valuable input when you are creating a new role or redesigning a team.

When to commission a market map

  • Before launching a search for a critical or hard-to-fill role.
  • When planning succession for the leadership team.
  • Before a period of rapid growth, an acquisition or entry into a new market.
  • When designing a new function or senior role.
  • When the board wants an objective view of the strength of the current team against the market.

One-off map or ongoing intelligence?

A one-off map gives a snapshot that is most valuable at the moment it is produced. Markets move quickly, and a map that is a year old will already be out of date. For organisations where leadership talent is a primary driver of value, such as private equity portfolios, professional services firms and high-growth businesses, an ongoing approach keeps the map current and relationships with potential candidates warm, so that the business is never starting from scratch when a key role opens up. This is the basis of our executive talent advisory service.

Frequently asked questions

Is market mapping confidential?

It should be. A professional mapping exercise does not reveal the client to the market unless that has been agreed, and individuals’ details are handled in line with data protection requirements.

How long does market mapping take?

A focused map for a single role typically takes a few weeks, depending on how broad the target market is and whether soundings are included.

Is market mapping the same as executive search?

No, although it is often the first stage of one. A map describes the market; a search goes on to approach, assess and appoint a candidate.

Can a market map include internal candidates?

Yes. Including internal candidates allows the board to benchmark them directly against the external market.

Talk to us

If you are planning a senior hire or reviewing succession, find out more about our executive search and talent advisory services.

Chris Percival
Chris Percival
Founder & Managing Director
www.cjpi.com/about-us/chris-percival/

Chris Percival is the Founder & Managing Director of CJPI. He is a Fellow of the Institute of Leadership, studied Mergers & Acquisitions at Imperial College Business School and holds a Distinction from Oxford Brookes University.

Related Posts